Why? Log Out | Topics | Search
Moderators | Register | Edit Profile

Zillions of Games Discussion Forum » Designing Games for Zillions » Why? « Previous Next »

Author Message
Shane Freeman (Thegreathabudabi)
New member
Username: Thegreathabudabi

Post Number: 28
Registered: 7-2008
Posted on Sunday, August 10, 2008 - 12:40 pm:   

I imagine this would be a question better asked of the designers of Zillions, but since they no longer care about it, maybe someone else knows something about this.

Since ZoG sucks pretty badly at anything but 2 player games, and only 2 player games can be played over a network/internet connection, why the hell did they even include the option to create games with up to 32 players? This does not make sense to me.

And here's one for you Mats. You are quite opposed to my 4 player chess variant. My friends and I also have an 8 player chess variant that we play, which I've now programmed with ZoG.

- Shane
Greg Schmidt (Gschmidt2)
New member
Username: Gschmidt2

Post Number: 72
Registered: 1-2007
Posted on Sunday, August 10, 2008 - 2:23 pm:   

Well as someone who has spent a fair amount of time trying to learn the internals of Zillions by a combination of experimentation and channeling the designers, I'm at least as qualified as anyone else to speculate.

First of all, it's not clear to me that the net play limitation you encountered was by design. It may have never been tested or perhaps worked once but then broke due to some other change. Note: It might be interesting to try some earlier versions of Zillions to determine if it ever worked.

As far as multi-player games are concerned, even though AI performance drops exponentially with the number of players, there may be other reasons to support multi-player games. Here are some thoughts.

- The notion of a Zillions "game" is pretty broad in some respects. Just look at some of Karl Scherer's creations to get an idea (e.g. drawing tools, educational examples, and puzzles). My own Marquand Logic Machine is an example of one of these "offbeat" novelties. So a player could represent any "participant" in an abstract machine that involves multiple agents that may have diverse goals and are able to manipulate symbols across a network of positions.

- One could devise a game where most participants play randomly. For example, a slot machine where each indicator represents a player.

- I realize this is a weak point, but Zillions can be used as a board simulator. You could pass the laptop around to the next person when it's their turn to play.

- As far as 32 players are concerned, it goes back to my first point. Why build in limitations when we don't know how the software will be used by others? I doubt the -=Creators=- could have anticipated all the offbeat ways in which the product would have been used - and perhaps they realized that. I've seen others complain on this board about limitations that I would have never expected to be a problem, but for some particular need, sometimes an unlikely capability becomes crucial. I'm old enough to remember when the IBM PC first came out. The designers provided for a maximum of 640K with the stated belief that "no one would ever need more than that".

It's difficult to put out a "universal" product such as Zillions and expect to satisfy everyone. Judging by all of the requests and criticism that has transpired on this board (some overcritical or downright nasty), I wonder if the designers dropped off because they were overwhelmed with it. It would take several lifetimes to even begin addressing all of the feature requests. The whole product would have to be redesigned from the ground up with a completely different philosophy in order to address most of them.

-- Greg
M Winther (Kalroten)
New member
Username: Kalroten

Post Number: 93
Registered: 1-2007
Posted on Monday, August 11, 2008 - 12:03 am:   

I, for my part, have implemented "I Ching", the Chinese oracle. A couple of weeks ago I asked it whether I should take the opportunity to move to a new apartment. But Zillions I Ching replied: "Stay put." The "bird" should not fly, etc. So I decided to stay.

As an example of simulation, there is also an implementation of the "Game of Life", i.e. different variants that have been presented in Scientific American.

Moreover, even if Zillions doesn't play the game well, the implementation can be used anyway to demonstrate the pros and cons of a variant, i.e. you can see how it works. I have noted that many people underestimate Zillions chess playing ability. Probably this is due to premature queen excursions and the fact that it moves knights and camels to much in the opening. But this can be easily amended by discouraging early queen moves and encouraging centre pawn moves. Then it plays a good game of chess.

It's certainly not easy to beat Zillions in checkers games. Like Greg says, it's somewhat underestimated as a tool, but it's also underestimated when it comes to playing capability.

An important aspect of Zillions is historical research. My 4-handed Shatranj (For Seasons Chess) needed to be implemented as a matter of "historical research". I have implemented several historical games, like those patterns that appeared in Augusta Raurica, and which prof. Schädler suspected were roman bear games. Now he doesn't "suspect" it any more. It turns out that it works even better than he suspected, because only three hunters are needed.

I have also researched many historical hare games sent to me by P. Michaelsen. It turned out that several of them were defunct and must probably be regarded as ideograms. It also turned out that van der Stoep's findings about the true rules of roman/medieval Alquerque were correct. In my implementation it's evident that the roman author was correct who describes the game as somewhat advantageous for the second party.

The conclusion is that Zillions is very useful. While checkers has been solved I recently suggested an 8x10 board stood on end. It's so easy to implement, but it's so valuable for serious checkers players to use for testing.

There is also an artistic aspect to this, and a form of mandala creation. Many people create mandalas in coloured sand, or paint. Some do it in Zillions code. Examples of this are the games of Markus Salo, which use Swedish place names. This tradition, of viewing games as mandalas, is an ancient tradition. They inscribed them everywhere, on temple walls, etc. An editor of Ps. Perspectives suggested that I submit an article about it. I will notify this forum if the article is accepted. (It would be slightly sensational)
/Mats
Greg Schmidt (Gschmidt2)
New member
Username: Gschmidt2

Post Number: 73
Registered: 1-2007
Posted on Monday, August 11, 2008 - 8:55 pm:   

Mats, would you be willing to elaborate a bit more on the relationship of games to Mandalas? What sorts of games would these be? Would they classify as abstracts?
-- Greg
M Winther (Kalroten)
New member
Username: Kalroten

Post Number: 94
Registered: 1-2007
Posted on Monday, August 11, 2008 - 11:04 pm:   

A mandala could look like anything, I suppose, as long as it conveys a feeling of spiritual wholeness. Also a triangle could be a mandala, like the Christian symbol seen on churches with an eye in the middle. Historically, game patterns have been used as mandalas, presumably as protective designs, etc. For instance, the different morris patterns have been very popular to inscribe on floors and walls. R. Vasantha describes this phenomenon in "Board Games Depicted as Murals" in Scientific Research on the Pictorial Arts of Asia, Jett, P. (ed.). Murray gives some examples too. Although a common phenomenon, it doesn't seem to be a well-researched area.
/Mats
Karl Scherer (Karl)
New member
Username: Karl

Post Number: 368
Registered: 9-2000
Posted on Wednesday, September 03, 2008 - 6:29 pm:   

A free Mandala drawing game:

A free Mandala drawing game (non-Zillions) I have written has been available for a few months on my website
(see free games page).

http://karl.kiwi.gen.nz

Cheers, Karl

Add Your Message Here
Post:
Username: Posting Information:
This is a private posting area. Only registered users and moderators may post messages here.
Password:
Options: Enable HTML code in message
Automatically activate URLs in message
Action: